Results Under Scrutiny
Every result starts with a pressure point.
Attempted Murder
- Their Assumption
- They said the evidence proved it
- Pressure Point
- The evidence didn't match the accusation
- What Broke
- Targeted scrutiny exposed the weakness
Result: Not Guilty
Phoenix Marijuana DUI
- Their Assumption
- Impairment from THC and alcohol
- Pressure Point
- The science did not support the conclusion
- What Broke
- The impairment narrative collapsed
Result: Evidence Suppressed
Transportation of Narcotic Drugs
Over 1000 pounds
- Their Assumption
- Over 1000 pounds meant prison
- Pressure Point
- The case depended on the search
- What Broke
- The search violated the Fourth Amendment
Result: Probation, No Incarceration
Scottsdale Extreme DUI
(0.174 BAC)
- Their Assumption
- The blood alcohol result was reliable and valid
- Pressure Point
- The collection and measurement process
- What Broke
- The measurement foundation
Result: Not Guilty
Vehicular Manslaughter
- Their Assumption
- They claimed speed caused the crash
- Pressure Point
- The reconstruction depended on camera angle and roadway geometry
- What Broke
- The reconstruction failed under geometric scrutiny
Result: Probation, No Incarceration
Negligent Homicide
Death of a police officer
- Their Assumption
- Driver caused the officer's death
- Pressure Point
- Grand jury presentation
- What Broke
- The Causal Link
Result: Case Dismissed
Different accusations. Same method.
Don't let their assumption become the result.
Attempted Murder & Aggravated Assault
- Their Assumption
- They said the evidence proved it
- Pressure Point
- The evidence didn't match the accusation
- What Broke
- Targeted scrutiny exposed the weakness
Not Guilty
Marijuana DUI
- Their Assumption
- THC and alcohol caused impairment
- Pressure Point
- The science did not support the conclusion
- What Broke
- The impairment narrative collapsed
Evidence Suppressed
Negligent Homicide
Death of a police officer
- Their Assumption
- Driver caused the officer's death
- Pressure Point
- Grand jury presentation
- What Broke
- The Causal Link
Case Dismissed
Scottsdale Extreme DUI
(0.174 BAC)
- Their Assumption
- The blood alcohol result was reliable and valid
- Pressure Point
- The collection and measurement process
- What Broke
- The measurement foundation
Not Guilty
Vehicular Manslaughter
- Their Assumption
- They claimed speed caused the crash
- Pressure Point
- The reconstruction depended on camera angle and roadway geometry.
- What Broke
- The reconstruction failed under geometric scrutiny
Probation and No Incarceration